A quietly enjoyable book, immersed in its environment (small town, South of England, WW2) featuring a collection of local characters. A very promising concept, a choir becoming the emotional center for a community under stress. Unfortunately, I found the story to be overly romanticized, full of clichés and the writer, in undertaking to tell the story through many voices, overreached, i.e. not all of them rang true, especially that of Kitty, the 13 year old, using language and imagery in her "diary" that no one would include at that age. And the ending was wrapped up altogether too neatly. Accordingly, 2 1/2 stars.

wyenotgo's rating:
[]
[]
To Top